Thursday, 07 July 2022 17:35

AMTA says aviation allegations around 5G interference are rhetoric, not fact

Rate this item
(0 votes)

AMTA, the Australian Mobile Telecommunications Association - and peak national body representing Australia’s mobile telecommunications industry - says recent media claims from the aviation industry are not based in fact, and that the aviation industry has failed to engage in the ACMA Technical Liaison Group on the matter.

The aviation industry has stated its belief that 5G services may potentially adversely impact radio altimeters used to assist with landing aircraft.

AMTA says it is disappointed the aviation industry has chosen to play out issues regarding altimeters and potential 5G interference in the public domain, despite failing to engage in the ACMA Technical Liaison Group (TLG) on this matter.

AMTA further says the aviation industry has yet to provide sufficient evidence in support of its claims that 5G services will interfere with radio altimeters, and that it has not provided any detail on the technical specifications and performance characteristics of altimeters in service after multiple requests for them to do so.

Despite this, AMTA says the aviation industry continues to use emotive language and to assert without evidence that aircraft safety is at risk from 5G services that may use the 3.4 to 4.0 GHz bands. AMTA says the approach is only stoking public fear about a problem that has not been substantiated and is an unhelpful approach.

The issue was first raised by US aviation industry group RTCA in an October 2020 study. Before, the US FCC had found that the technical rules and the guard band between 5G and radio altimeters were “sufficient to protect (aviation) services in the 4.2-4.4GHz band.”

The GSMA report says “RTCA avoided giving detailed, non-aggregated deployment information on radio altimeter models currently being used and only some anonymised information was provided publicly by RTCA’s research partner in late 2021.”

AMTA head of spectrum and network infrastructure Chris Coughlan said, “The aviation industry in Australia has likewise refused to provide detailed specifications of radio altimeters in service in Australia to the ACMA TLG.”

The GSMA report further states key studies used by the aviation industry in support of their demands for interference mitigation measures from the mobile sector are “based on highly pessimistic, overprotective and theoretical operational scenarios that together would not occur in live radio network implementations”.

“The mobile industry stands ready to mitigate any real issues that the aviation industry can factually demonstrate," Coughlan said. "However, at this time the aviation industry is refusing to share any detailed technical information so that a wider audience of radio experts can examine the real data and assess the probability of any potential hazards."

AMTA says it is important to start with the facts and evaluate the evidence scientifically, not speak of worst-case scenarios with hidden assumptions.

AMTA notes Japan has implemented mitigations and only in the 4 - 4.1GHz band, near airports. This band is not intended for 5G use in Australia, and AMTA says this is an additional guard and evidence that Australia has over-achieved on the Japanese levels of mitigation. AMTA says the aviation industry has "conveniently failed" to mention the Japan example.

In fact, AMTA says it's likely to be the case the aviation industry's worst-case scenario applies to old technology that already should have retired years, if not decades, ago. AMTA is aware of updated altimeters with superior filtering capabilities and says the aviation industry would be wiser considering acquiring these if they remain concerned about 5G impacts.

AMTA further states no examples of interference have been shown in any market, with all the examples cited by the aviation industry being equipment failures. The examples actually serve to underpin AMTA's concern that outdated equipment should be replaced by the aviation sector to ensure the ongoing safety of air personnel and passengers, they say.

“The Government agencies in Australia such as the ACMA and CASA are fact-based bodies that rely on clear evidence and science in establishing risk. The aviation industry has yet to contribute to this fact-based process, instead resorting to emotive rhetoric which may only serve to deny Australian businesses and consumers of the benefits of 5G services around airports," Coughlan said.


Thoughtworks presents XConf Australia, back in-person in three cities, bringing together people who care deeply about software and its impact on the world.

In its fifth year, XConf is our annual technology event created by technologists for technologists.

Participate in a robust agenda of talks as local thought leaders and Thoughtworks technologists share first-hand experiences and exchange new ways to empower teams, deliver quality software and drive innovation for responsible tech.

Explore how at Thoughtworks, we are making tech better, together.

Tickets are now available and all proceeds will be donated to Indigitek, a not-for-profit organisation that aims to create technology employment pathways for First Nations Peoples.

Click the button below to register and get your ticket for the Melbourne, Sydney or Brisbane event



It's all about Webinars.

Marketing budgets are now focused on Webinars combined with Lead Generation.

If you wish to promote a Webinar we recommend at least a 3 to 4 week campaign prior to your event.

The iTWire campaign will include extensive adverts on our News Site and prominent Newsletter promotion and Promotional News & Editorial. Plus a video interview of the key speaker on iTWire TV which will be used in Promotional Posts on the iTWire Home Page.

Now we are coming out of Lockdown iTWire will be focussed to assisting with your webinars and campaigns and assistance via part payments and extended terms, a Webinar Business Booster Pack and other supportive programs. We can also create your adverts and written content plus coordinate your video interview.

We look forward to discussing your campaign goals with you. Please click the button below.


David M Williams

David has been computing since 1984 where he instantly gravitated to the family Commodore 64. He completed a Bachelor of Computer Science degree from 1990 to 1992, commencing full-time employment as a systems analyst at the end of that year. David subsequently worked as a UNIX Systems Manager, Asia-Pacific technical specialist for an international software company, Business Analyst, IT Manager, and other roles. David has been the Chief Information Officer for national public companies since 2007, delivering IT knowledge and business acumen, seeking to transform the industries within which he works. David is also involved in the user group community, the Australian Computer Society technical advisory boards, and education.

Related items

  • Jimboomba gains stronger broadband connection with new Optus tower

    Telecommunications company Optus has switched on a tower in Jimboomba, serving the population of 8,000 residents.

    “We’re proud to enhance coverage of our Optus network in regional South Queensland with the addition of a new tower in Jimboomba which has mid and high band 5G deployed in addition to our 4G coverage and capacity layers,” said Optus territory general manager South Queensland Nick Channell.

    The new tower is part of Optus’ infrastructure and mobile coverage expansion in South Queensland. With seven new sites built since 2020, Optus said the tower would provide coverage and capacity to the area and offer an alternative for residents and businesses in Jimboomba.

    “Alongside the new mobile tower, Jimboomba’s Optus store accompanies the improved 4G and 5G connectivity and capacity, offering our network and services at a great value, and further facilitating competition and choice for local businesses and residents,” added Channell.

    {loadposition kenn}

    The store has worked with the local community to ensure residents remain connected and can access Optus services when they need them most.

    This first appeared in the subscription newsletter CommsWire on 12 August 2022.

  • Ericsson and SkyMax Network to build 5G in Africa

    Wireless communications engineering company SkyMax Network and telecommunications company Ericsson has entered into an agreement to build a next generation 5G broadband network covering digital services delivery platform across the Sub-Saharan Africa.

    The memorandum of understanding (MoU) prescribes that Ericsson will be SkyMax’s partner for network supply, rollout, and optimisation for managed services.

    Ericsson will explore partnership opportunities in end-to-end business and technology solutions including radio access and mobile transport network solutions, core network and provisioning systems, business support systems, and managed services including cognitive software network optimisations and business consulting support.

    “Over the last two years, we have collaborated with Ericsson to bring the best offerings to Sub-Saharan Africa with a focus on accelerating 5G adoption to drive financial and social inclusion while reducing carbon dioxide emissions and increasing energy efficiency,” said SkyMax president and CEO Wilfrid Aissi.

    SkyMax’s 5G Digital Service Delivery Platform (5G DSDP) is a data network that offers network slicing, ultra-low latency, internet of things, edge computing, cloud computing, cloud telephony and network exposure function or NEF (NEF enables third-party developers and enterprises to create and tailor their own network services on-demand on SkyMax 5G DSDP), all of which create opportunities.

    {loadposition kenn}

    SkyMax intends to increase the development of broadband networks in SSA by sharing its 5G DSDP with incumbent service providers by using its 5G network slicing technologies.

    In SSA, SkyMax plans to launch SkyMax Entrepreneurship Development (SED) to develop its private 5G network for new markets and applications.

    SkyMax will train and certify service providers, individuals, and businesses so they can best take advantage of the value private 5G will bring to areas such as e-agriculture, smart buildings, and smart cities.

    These entrepreneur partners will be able to develop their own private 5G businesses on SkyMax 5G DSDP for revenue sharing.

    As part of the MoU, SkyMax will also be able to tap Ericsson’s technologies and global deployment experience in network design, network management, and market development.

    “We look forward to working with SkyMax Network to capture the opportunities that we can offer the region together and accelerate #AfricaInMotion,” concluded Ericsson vice president and head South and East Africa Todd Ashton.

    This first appeared in the subscription newsletter CommsWire on 11 August 2022.

  • Maaaate... Mate offers $40 5G plan with 60GB monthly data, 500GB rollover, unlimited calls and text, and more!

    Mobile virtual network operator and Internet provider Mate wants to be your best mate with a high value mobile plan, using the Telstra network, with great inclusions and low prices that will surely be very tempting to a lot of smartphone users.

    Mate. The company in an Australian owned Internet, NBN and mobile virrtual network operator of note, and it could very easily become your best Mate for quality, service and pricing!

    I previously video interviewed Mate GM Mark Fazio nearly a year ago, and learned what a great Internet and mobile provider the company is, with really competitive pricing, "mates rates" on various goods and services, Australian customer service and more, and I've been happy to follow the company's impressive progress.

    Now comes news of Mate's latest date with destiny, with the launch of an excellent value postpaid 5G plan, with no contracts, continuing its track record of providing top-notch service at a fantastic price for its Aussie customers.

    Indeed, Mate says its new 5G plan "is the best value 5G plan on the market using the Telmatestra Wholesale mobile network."

    This plan has 60GB of data, a data bank rollover feature that lets you store up to 500GB of unused monthly data, the inclusion of the global music streaming platform Tidal, unlimited national talk and text to standard Aussie numbers, and even unlimited international calls and SMS to 15 selected countries, which include Canada, China, Germany, Greece, Hong Kong, India, Ireland, Malaysia, New Zealand, Singapore, South Korea, Thailand, United Kingdom, USA and Vietnam.

    Even better still, this is all for the low-cost introductory offer of $40 per month – and when Mate says it’s possibly the best in the market overall, it certainly will be hard to beat.

    Image credit: Mate's 5G $40 plan details

    It reminds me of when Amaysim, now owned by Optus, launched what was a game changing plan a decade ago, when it offered unlimited calls and text to Australian numbers, and a then whopping 4GB. There were no included calls to overseas numbers, there were no data bank options, but at the time, it was a great deal.

    Fast forward to 2022, and we have the modern equivalent. The Telstra Wholesale cap on 5G speeds is 250Mbps, and while those directly on the Telstra network can get faster 5G speeds, a 250Mbps cap is still much faster than the 4G peak speed of 100Mbps, so those with a 5G-capable phone but who have been stuck on a 4G plan will certainly feel the difference.

    Even those on a 5G plan directly with one of the three major carriers is unlikely to notice any differences.

    As Mate notes, "5G also provides Aussies with greater bandwidth, so users can look forward to taking advantage of their data. From seamless 4K video calls to being able to download a movie in seconds, the 5G plan offers an exceptionally high-performance experience no matter what your mobile needs are."

    Mark Fazio, Co-CEO of MATE, noted his pleasure at Mate being able to continue bringing its unique brand of local telco services at fantastic prices to the community, and stated: "The 5G mobile network gives Australians the speed and performance they’re looking for with even less lag time than ever before. We’re thrilled to be able to offer Aussie consumers this great result at a price that’s more affordable than ever.:

    Mate is also proud to note its use of the Telstra Wholesale network, which uses parts of Telstra’s 5G, 4G and 3G mobile networks in providing services to customers.

    {loadposition alex08}

    Currently, 5G coverage reaches at least 75% of the Australian population, which is a huge boost, with the entire Telstra mobile coverage footprint covers more than 1.6 million square kilometres and reaches more than 98.8% of the Australian population.

    Mark concludes: "We’ve been apart for too long. Our new soul mates 5G plan will help families and friends stay in touch whether they’re here in Australia or overseas. And it’s not going to cost them an arm and leg to do that. With the current economic situation, we feel good about that."

    Now, I had some questions, which included what the time limit was on the introductory pricing, whether the current 100GB 4G plan will move to 5G at some point, and whether Mate's service allowed users to have the same number added to their Apple Watch, which is something that is only reserved for the main carriers themselves.

    The answers I received were as follows:

    "The introductory price does not currently have an end date and the team doesn't have a set price that it will move to. Any customers on the $40 per month plan will continue to pay $40 even if the offer ends.

    "4G and 5G Plans are separate and the 100GB won’t become 5G. They may at some point have a 100GB 5G plan however they have no set date for this. In the future, all plans will be 5G capable.

    "The 5G plan is not an eSIM plan. They are looking at plan and bundle options around eSim which would enable devices such as smartwatches and tablets to have a data plan without a physical SIM card. This would also allow eligible handsets to have a second phone number via eSim in addition to a physical SIM."

    So, if you have an Apple Watch and want it to have the same number as your iPhone, you'll be forced to stick with Telstra, Optus or Vodafone direct, and you can't connect the Mate 5G service to an eSIM plan.

    Hopefully, those are just limitations for now, and will one day be removed, but they're things currently beyond Mate's control.

    The plan puts up a great fight against Boost Mobile, another great MVNO on the Telstra network, and the full 4G network at that, which would be greater coverage than Mate, but for most living in the cities, extra regional coverage won't make much of a difference. Boost also doesn't yet offer 5G.

    Another difference is that Boost lets you call any country, with a limit of 300 minutes of international calls and texts, as opposed to full unlimited to the 15 countries listed above its Mate.

    Boost doesn't offer data banking either, which is certainly a consideration for some.

    So, Mate's new 5G mobile plan is definitely competitive, and an excellent deal for those who want access to the Telstra network without having to pay Telstra prices, while data banking up to a whopping 500GB.

    It's great, mate!

  • Public cloud 5G workloads to hit $6.6 billion in the next five years: Dell’Oro Group

    5G workloads on public cloud will grow revenues at an 88% compounded annual growth rate with cumulative revenues estimated to hit at US$4.6 billion ($6.6 billion) over the next five years from 2022 to 2026, according to Dell’Oro Group’s 5G Workloads on the Public Cloud report.

    The report found that majority of 5G standalone networks will be in the telco cloud, limiting the short-term opportunity for the public cloud to host 5G workloads.

    "At first glance, this may appear to be a very conservative forecast. Especially in view of Hyperscale Cloud Providers' (HCPs) plethora of press releases that suggest there is greater traction in the marketplace than previously identified,” declared Dell’Oro Group research director Dave Bolan.

    “The new report discovers that the opportunity for HCPs to penetrate the telco cloud market is very limited in the short-term, with the momentum already established by mobile network operators (MNOs) committing to the telco cloud," said Bolan.

    {loadposition kenn}

    "Most of the HCP press releases are about HCPs adding network solutions for enterprises that desire 5G device connectivity via a Hybrid Cloud at the edge location. Our projections are for public cloud revenues, not hybrid clouds at the edge of the networks,” clarified Bolan.

    Bolan said they found 27 5G standalone networks have been deployed and only one MNO is running its 5G workloads in the public cloud.

    “The balance chose to run their own telco cloud. Further findings show that another 130 MNOs have already cut contracts with 5G core vendors to deploy their own telco clouds, and two MNOs have committed to run their networks in the public cloud.”

    "For the short-term, HCPs are focusing on the enterprise opportunities extending their services to the network edge, either themselves or partnering with an MNO integrating their services inside the telco cloud.”

    “Longer term there is much more opportunity for the HCPs to host 5G workloads in their public clouds with 75 5G non-standalone (5G NSA) MNOs and another 600 LTE MNOs still to announce their 5G SA plans. The forecast exits 2026 with a higher year-over-year percentage growth rate for 5G workloads moving to the public cloud than for the growth rate of the telco cloud," Bolan concluded.

    This first appeared in the subscription newsletter CommsWire on 4 August 2022.

  • Ericsson and Vodafone launch support service for 5G-factory in Hungary

    Telecommunications company Ericsson and Vodafone have launched a service continuity for private networks aimed at improving manufacturing and industrial efficiency.

    The solution is now being deployed by Vodafone’s enterprise customer, electronics manufacturer and technology solutions provider Foxconn in its factory in Komárom, Hungary.

    Ericsson’s private networks are offering enterprises such as Foxconn a wireless connectivity that can transform the core of business-critical operations.

    Ericsson said the solution can prevent network outages and reduces the risk of costly downtime by identifying and averting such as risks.

    {loadposition kenn}

    Based on artificial intelligence and machine learning, it can pre-emptively sense if something might result in a degradation of performance.

    Corrective actions are then taken by Vodafone locally together with Ericsson’s centralised team to avert such an occurrence, ensuring uptimes that are better than in traditional telecom networks.

    “Foxconn relies on non-fixed 5G-based test cars, on which newly manufactured PCs are tested before packaging at their plant in Hungary. To ensure that the private network connecting these test cars is as reliable as possible, Vodafone and Ericsson have jointly developed and deployed the custom-built service contunuity for private networks support and technical assistance for enterprises that ensures smooth network operations,” Ericsson said in a statement.

    “We are very conscious of the trust placed by Foxconn in Vodafone and have worked jointly with Ericsson to create this unique technical assistance offering for enterprises to ensure that the operation of their private networks is free of unplanned interruptions,” said Vodafone business director Mátyás Dobó.

    “We are constantly working with Vodafone to evolve the private networks space for enterprises, and this AI and ML-based support service is a testimony to that work. Added to this is the flexibility to change production setup without disruption, and to adapt to changing business needs,” said Ericsson business area networks head of strategy and portfolio management Nello Califano.

    This first appeared in the subscription newsletter CommsWire on 3 August 2022.




Guest Opinion

Guest Interviews

Guest Reviews

Guest Research

Guest Research & Case Studies

Channel News