Labor Senators spent six months seeking to establish the reference for this claim, Rowland says.
However, Rowland continues, after the Minister proved unable to produce any page reference for his “source”, the Department cut him loose and effectively advised the Senate the Minister swindled them as well, saying, "The Department does not manage the Minister’s Twitter account and did not provide advice on the Minister’s statement to the House of Representatives."
"In other words, there was no source, the Minister is just making things up, and even public officials are getting fed up with his persistent attempts to mislead.
"Minister Fletcher needs to accept he is presiding over a $57 billion technology omelette that costs more to build, costs more to operate, but delivers less than the original fibre plan.
"No amount of hyperventilating in Parliament will change that fact," Rowland concludes.
Reflecting on the past
Most of us accept the fact that the coalition when they came to office, with Malcolm Turnbull as the Minister, had to put a Coalition spin on the NBN. I wrote a report back in 2011/12, for Telsyte, that examined two scenarios, one in which Labor continued and another in which the Coalition won the 2013 federal election. I predicted that the Coalition wouldn't kill the NBN but change its direction to what they called the Multi-Technology Mix. I forecasted a very accurate technology mix, for a Coalition managed NBN, out to 2017, in the report.
The Coalition Government, peddled out the Strategic Review, published in December 2013, to justify the change in direction.
The Coalition Government then commissioned the very flawed report, "Domestic bandwidth requirements in Australia, A forecast for the period 2013-2023", by Communications Chambers, published in May 2014. This report was used to sell a lower quality Multi-Technology Mix solution to the Australian people.
At the time I wrote a response that questioned many of the assumptions made in that report; those assumptions were all set to favour lower throughput outcomes. How low was this prediction, look at figure 3 from that report below.
The report predicted that the median household in Australia only needed downstream bandwidth of 15Mbps in 2023, justifying the poorest access technology positioned in the Strategic Review, FTTN. So the then Government commissioned this bull, to justify its supposedly cheaper NBN, that in the end wasn't.
I do feel for the current Minister, Paul Fletcher, he has inherited this basket case, that now needs a mountain of additional capital to correct the flawed technology choices made by his predecessor.