And there is nothing being put forward by the old-school libertarian campaign crowd that has been able to undo the damage being done by a hardcore set of misguided geek activists.
There is nothing like the internet filter debate to bring out the worst in people. And so it has been with the reaction to my last column chiding internet ferals.
Yes, the term 'internet ferals' is inflammatory and unnecessary. You're right. You got me there. But the debate within the tech community has been so counterproductive, and so full of disinformation and rubbish, I simply could not help myself.
Forgive me, please.
Nah, I don't mean that. There is an element of the anti-filter crowd that has been so damaging to the broader, mainstream campaign that they need to be called out. If you don't like the term internet ferals, think of yourselves as idiots. You know who you are.
In the meantime, here are some thoughts about the campaign, which is not going well.
There are some real problems. Not least that this noisy minority is killing any chance of bringing onboard the mass of reasonably-minded, moderate, everyday Australian voters that are needed to effectively influence the process.
And that makes it difficult for the Opposition senators who are uncomfortable with the filter plan. It makes it more difficult for them to get vocal, let alone try and bring their colleagues along with them.
For the benefit of the noisy minority: It helps to be positive. It is more effective to be FOR something, rather than simply AGAINST something else.
Much better to argue the very real merits of the existing open regime for the internet - to put forward the very reasonable case that the existing environment has served us well. It is much more productive to point out what we are putting at risk by considering even this mild set of internet censorship plans.
Secondly, abuse does not help. Whether the abuse is aimed at Stephen Conroy, his staff, Kevin Rudd, journalists, or others in an electronic forum who might wonder aloud whether there should be limits to freedom of expression, abuse does nothing except distract potential supporters from the reasonable arguments that the anti-filter campaign has at its disposal.
Thirdly, the disinformation and hyperbole being put forward by the extreme elements of the debate are a gross distortion to the point of being fundamentally dishonest. Start campaigning against the scheme that is being introduced rather campaigning against a more sinister made-up version of it. Dishonesty does not impress people.
Stop whining. And stop the obsession with Stephen Conroy as being some kind of Dark Rider in league with the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. The filter started as ALP policy (if poorly articulated) and has been a policy of this Government.
The policy started life in a kind of game of one-upmanship with the then Coalition government, which saw votes in cleaning up the internet and which had a backbench full of filter agitators. Then Communications Minister Helen Coonan was saddled with that particularly turd sandwich, and managed to hose it down as best she could.
Conroy inherited this policy. Who knows what he actually feels about it, and who cares? Cabinet wants it done and the Government could not have been clearer about its intentions.
Start talking to people who can actually influence the process. And at this point, that is the Liberal Party. The Greens have already said they will vote against filter. Which means the government needs the Opposition to vote with it to get the filter passed in the Senate.
There are a many Opposition senators who are uncomfortable with the very notion of an internet filter. But there are many who are supportive of it. And you do the moderates no favours by seeding the debate with intentionally misinformed vitriol.
Finally, the No Clean Feed slogan is completely ridiculous and counterproductive. Not exactly the kind of message that is likely to capture the imagination of millions of time-poor mum's and dad's who already feel uncomfortable with the internet. While the Electronic Frontiers Australia organisation is now doing something about this, it is very late in the game.
To paraphrase my colleague David Heath, the campaign would do itself a favour if it stopped presenting itself as outraged geeks and started to instead behave like informed and reasonable voters.
Featured IT News
Reliable access to broadband, mobile, landline services in focus for ACCAN conference
08 August 2022 in Telecoms & NBNEnsuring that consumers have reliable access to broadband, mobile and landline services, no matter where they live in Australia, is…
Australia not spared as APAC region to lose 63 million jobs to automation: forecast
08 August 2022 in Enterprise StaffAustralia will see 11% of jobs lost to automation by 2040, according to the latest jobs forecast for the APAC…
Australia ranks 8th globally in government surveillance: study
08 August 2022 in SecurityGlobally, during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of accounts specified in data requests for government surveillance…
Xero revamps APAC leadership team
05 August 2022 in People MovesCloud accounting software provider Xero is moving to a regional leadership structure.
Fortinet buoyed by ‘strong’ quarterly revenue, billings growth
04 August 2022 in Listed TechCybersecurity firm Fortinet has recorded strong revenue and billings growth for the three months to the end of June 2022.
Complexica hires senior trio
04 August 2022 in People MovesAI-based sales, marketing and supply chain software specialist Complexica has appointed Dr Soner Teknikeler to the role of senior manager,…
Lam leads SoftServe's APAC product and design practice
04 August 2022 in People MovesDigital consultancy SoftServe has appointed Yishan Lam to the role of head of product and design for the APAC market.
Tablet, chromebook shipments down globally for fourth quarter running
04 August 2022 in HardwareGlobal shipments of tablets fell for the fourth quarter running, with the technology analyst firm Canalys reporting a 11% year-on-year…
Oppo releases two models of A77 5G device in Australia
04 August 2022 in MobilityChinese smartphone vendor Oppo has released another device in its A series with a twist: there are two models, one…
Telstra to address ACCC's 5G competition concerns
03 August 2022 in Technology RegulationThe ACCC has accepted a court-enforceable undertaking from Telstra to address competition concerns relating to the 5G rollout.
Sanjay Poonen appointed Cohesity CEO and president
03 August 2022 in People MovesNext-gen data management company Cohesity has appointed former VMware and SAP senior executive Sanjay Poonen as CEO and president.
TOPdesk appoints new GM for Australia
03 August 2022 in People MovesService management specialist TOPdesk Australia has appointed Robert van der Gulik to the role of general manager.
Domain administrator auDA records strong growth in .au direct names registrations
03 August 2022 in Technology RegulationAustralia’s domain administrator auDA had 170,000 .au direct names registered by the end of the June 2022 quarter and CEO…
Sandes leads Wasabi in Australia
03 August 2022 in People MovesHot cloud storage provider Wasabi Technologies has appointed Andrew Sandes to the role of country manager for Australia.
DCI announces Canberra data centre
03 August 2022 in Data CentresDCI Data Centers is entering the Canberra data centre market with a 20MW site in the Poplars Innovation Precinct in…
Breaking IT News
KnowBe4 forms investment arm KnowBe4 Ventures
08 August 2022 in SecuritySecurity awareness specialist KnowBe4 has formed KnowBe4 Ventures to co-invest in security startups to strengthen and support cybersecurity initiatives.
Acusensus AI software detects drivers who use mobile phones while on the road
08 August 2022 in Business SoftwareTraffic management solutions Acusensus has developed an AI software to catch dangerous drivers who are using their mobile phones while…
Talend announces support for Amazon Redshift Serverless
08 August 2022 in DealsData integration and governance provider Talend has announced its support for Amazon Redshift Serverless.
Mission-critical communications to reach more areas in NSW with 250 public safety network radio sites
08 August 2022 in Technology RegulationThe NSW Government has delivered 250 enhanced public safety network radio sites reaching more than 97% of NSW’s population and…
Renesas unveils RZ/A3UL microprocessors
08 August 2022 in Business ITSemiconductor supplier solutions Renesas unveils the RZ/A3UL group of microprocessors that enable high-definition human-machine interface and quick start-up for applications…
Orange Egypt upgrades its Nokia SDM solution
08 August 2022 in Business TelecomsMobile network operator company Orange Egypt has upgraded its existing Nokia SDM solution to support its subscriber growth over the…
How Alibaba Cloud’s data centre will run on clean energy by 2030
08 August 2022 in Data CentresAlibaba Cloud is poised to meet its carbon reduction targets as it upgrades server-storing data centres around the world, according…
FC Bayern and Adobe partner to redefine fan experiences
05 August 2022 in DealsAdobe and FC Bayern, one of the world’s most historic and successful football clubs, announced a multi-year partnership to power…
4 non-profits bridging the digital divide for First Nations communities to share more than $750,000 in funding from INCO, supported by Google.org
05 August 2022 in Not For ProfitINCO, a non-profit supporting the growth of Australia’s social enterprise ecosystem, has announced the launch of its first Australian Digitisation…
UST opens innovation lab at University of Melbourne
05 August 2022 in Business ITDigital transformation solutions company UST today opened an innovation lab at the University of Melbourne’s Melbourne Connect.
Australians indifferent to space industry and are more likely to associate space with aliens than satellite communications: Inmarsat report
05 August 2022 in SpaceAustralia played a vital role in Apollo 11’s iconic moon landing in 1969. Half a century later tells a different…
Public cloud 5G workloads to hit $6.6 billion in the next five years: Dell’Oro Group
05 August 2022 in Cloud5G workloads on public cloud will grow revenues at an 88% compounded annual growth rate with cumulative revenues estimated to…
Reviews
-
The Peloton Guide is your on-screen guide that motivates, measures, and maximises your fitness goals
Peloton is well known for its exercise equipment, fashionable attire, and not least, its workouts. The fitness company…
- Type with mojo ... the MelGeek Mojo 84 mechanical keyboard, that is in Computers & peripherals
-
Protect your children's hearing with the FiiTii Kido kids Safe wireless headphones
The FiiTii Kido wireless headphones are a nifty set of headphones for young ones that sit nicely, look…
- The ALOGIC Iris USB Webcam A09 in Computers & peripherals
- The future is here: Lavazza and Amazon present Voicy - the smartest coffee machine ever in Computers & peripherals
-
Review: Oppo Reno8 Lite 5G is well worth a second look
By Sam Varghesein Smartphones & Mobile devices
-
The special edition EPOS Adapt 660 AMC Aston Martin headset takes your audio experience to the F1 level
The EPOS Adapt 660 AMC headset is the first new product arising from the relationship between the AV…
-
The tech-packed Sony WH1000-XM5 headphones make your music the whole world
Sony has released its fifth generation wireless noise-cancelling headphones. The company has set a high bar for itself…
-
The Nanoleaf Lines allow you to light your way - your way
The Nanoleaf Lines are a smart lighting package that allows you to enjoy amazing artworks of light, designed…
-
Sony Inzone gaming headsets maximises hearing quality for 'unparalleled' gaming experience
By Sony
COMPANY NEWS: Sony Australia unveils Inzone, a gear brand for that heightens gaming hearing experience—particularly video game sounds—for…
- Give your PC the upgrade it deserves with PNY XLR8 Gaming EPIC-X RGB DDR4 RAM in Computers & peripherals
-
Review: Oppo Find X5 Lite lives up to its name
By Sam Varghesein Smartphones & Mobile devices
- The SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro is coming, setting a new standard for gaming headsets, and your ears will thank you in Computers & peripherals
-
The Jabra Talk 65 is the Bluetooth headset for those who have things to do
There are headsets and there are headsets; some are designed for gaming, some for music, and some for…
-
Escape the desk and stay connected to all your devices with the Poly Voyager 4300 UC series
Poly's Voyager 4300 UC series brings comfort and style to office headsets, allowing you to freely roam up…
Opinion
-
ABC reports firms slyly collecting data, fails to disclose it's in same game
By Sam Varghese
The ABC has reported that learning software providers were slurping up data of students during the pandemic without…
-
No kidding, Microsoft now charges firms to tackle Windows ransomware
By Sam Varghese
Microsoft, the company that produces Windows which is the target of practically every ransomware attack, is now offering…
-
Nine's leaders' debate just a badly organised shouting match
By Sam Varghese
At the start of Sunday's so-called Great Debate between Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese,…
-
ABC unlikely to decide news presenter's fate before election is done
By Sam Varghese
The ABC appears unlikely to publicise any decision it makes about the future of news presenter Fauziah Ibrahim —…
-
Election campaign unmasks journalists for what they really are
By Sam Varghese
Eight years ago, the independent American journalist Matt Taibbi outlined what he thought was the best use which…
-
Google exposed as it bids to show up Microsoft over security
By Sam Varghese
Google's bid to position itself as some kind of competitor to Microsoft based on its security credentials has…
-
Murdoch, Zuckerberg, Bezos, Brin, Page are all A-okay. But Musk???
By Sam Varghese
The objections to Elon Musk buying Twitter can be distilled down to one simple thing: his policies will…
-
AFR shows it does not know difference between poll and focus group
By Sam Varghese
The Australian Financial Review, which claims to be one of the country's top newspapers, does not appear to…
-
Whatever happened to the government's ransomware action plan?
By Sam Varghese
Last October, with great fanfare, Home Affairs Minister Karen Andrews announced the Ransomware Action Plan, vowing to make…
Telecommunications
-
Singtel to invest additional US$100 million in ‘innovative technology’ start-ups through Singtel Innov8
By Staff Writer
Singapore telco Singtel plans to invest a further US$100 million into Singtel Innov8, its corporate venture arm, raising…
-
Reliable access to broadband, mobile, landline services in focus for ACCAN conference
By Staff Writer
Ensuring that consumers have reliable access to broadband, mobile and landline services, no matter where they live in…
Popular News
-
Oppo releases two models of A77 5G device in Australia
By Sam Varghese
Chinese smartphone vendor Oppo has released another device in its A series with a twist: there are two…
-
Complexica hires senior trio
AI-based sales, marketing and supply chain software specialist Complexica has appointed Dr Soner Teknikeler to the role of…
-
Fortinet buoyed by ‘strong’ quarterly revenue, billings growth
By Staff Writer
Cybersecurity firm Fortinet has recorded strong revenue and billings growth for the three months to the end of…
-
OfficeMax New Zealand sees better customer experience delivery with Seismic
Office supplier OfficeMax New Zealand has implemented Seismic Enablement Cloud, an enterprise-grade technology, to boost and yield better…
- Xero revamps APAC leadership team in People Moves
-
Australians indifferent to space industry and are more likely to associate space with aliens than satellite communications: Inmarsat report
Australia played a vital role in Apollo 11’s iconic moon landing in 1969. Half a century later tells…
-
RingCentral rolls out updates for its communication platforms
Contact centre solutions RingCentral has announced new features and updates for both of its business cloud phone system…
-
Ericsson and Vodafone launch support service for 5G-factory in Hungary
Telecommunications company Ericsson and Vodafone have launched a service continuity for private networks aimed at improving manufacturing and…
-
mycar Tyre & Auto picks Macquarie Telecom to modernise its network
More than 270 mycar Tyre & Auto stores across Australia have deployed Macquarie Telecom’s NBN and SD-WAN services,…
-
Macquarie Telecom joins VMware Sovereign Cloud initiative
Macquarie Telecom joins VMware Sovereign Cloud initiative, a reflection of the company’s commitment to sovereign IT capability.
-
Lam leads SoftServe's APAC product and design practice
Digital consultancy SoftServe has appointed Yishan Lam to the role of head of product and design for the…
-
UST opens innovation lab at University of Melbourne
Digital transformation solutions company UST today opened an innovation lab at the University of Melbourne’s Melbourne Connect.